Is free soloing dangerous reddit. climb. The problem with free soloing is that if you do die, best case scenario you're creating a horrific mess somebody else has to clean up; worst case scenario you're damaging the global climbing community with a high-profile accident that will make people think climbing is more dangerous and irresponsible than it is, inspire private landowners to Mar 30, 2024 · The Numbers: Free Solo Death Rates Let’s start with some cold hard numbers to get an idea of how much free solo contributes to solo climbing deaths and accidents. We talk about warning signs of putting yourself or others in harms way, I think The bit about free soloists dying threw me in for a loop and think, “WTF!”. Kind of amazing how many folks are soloing the yosemite moderates nowadays. Alex Huber has free soloed 14a. It just made me realize that free soloing isn't this scary, untouchable thing—you solo routes that are well within your ability, and don't let ego get involved, and it's actually a fantastic way to move over the rock without anything holding you back or dictating your pace. We were probably 30 ft. 6), Commitment (5. I’ve been passed by free soloists on Swan Slab Gully (5. Like everything, this is a nuanced topic. Basically it's a beautiful thing but the more you do it the more dangerous it gets just statistically you're more likely to screw up or have bad luck. Magnus Midtbø's Onsight Free Soloing Video with Alex Honnold was irresponsible when recorded and irresponsible when published. We all assume risks as climbers, but that risk is mitigated to a reasonable point. Unfortunately it is very common and alarmingly, from what I've observed it seems to be more common than in years past. more. But they're chasing the rush. [1] Free soloing is the most dangerous form of climbing, and, unlike bouldering, free soloists climb above safe See full list on expertclimbers. Reply reply Zeus1130 • fucking Reply reply more replyMore replies I just listened to the Hansjorg Auer Enormocast episode and he talked about the dangerous of soloing too much. That bit came off as disingenuous, they might as well have said, “OMG!!! Thanks for posting. I mean, in the case of free-soloing, everyone thinks it's stupid, dangerous, etc, etc. With all due respect, the person who passed seemed to have had a lot of experience both scrambling in the flatirons, and just generally with climbing - as well as being essentially a sub-elite trail runner. : r/climbing     Go to climbing r/climbing r/climbing While the video itself is really cool, it was mostly Magnus' fear that showed how incredibly scary and dangerous free soloing is. . Free-soloing is dangerous, simul-climbing is dangerous, crossing glaciers is dangerous, driving to the crag is dangerous, crag dogs can be dangerous. 8 slab but it was still maybe a 60 ft. Anyway, he free-solos to the top One would be to condemn free soloing but this should also entail us condemning some approach scrambles. Free soloing is unethical because in the event of a fall you are not the only victim Watching somebody die is a horrifying experience. up. In terms of climbing grades, Alex Honnold has done some hard free solo's but there are a few climbers who have solo'd harder routes - grade wise. Granted, it was a 5. I I'm guessing the couple treated it like an exposed hike, rather than what immediately springs to mind when I hear "Free solo" climbing. I respect people like Honnold for the initiatives he takes on with such a large platform, but can't take someone who thinks climbing 3000ft without any safeguards is a good idea seriously. It's overly glorified, unnecessarily dangerous, and those who participate in it have a real problem that needs real attention. When I read about free-soloing, for the most part I think, "Whatever floats their boat. " But when I was climbing outside awhile back, while rappelling after cleaning a climb, I saw a man free-soloing past me. When it comes to rock climbing as a whole, it is a generally safe sport. 8) and Royal Arches (5. Now it's one of my favorite ways to climb. The mountains are an inherently unstable and dangerous environment: avalanches, rockfall, crevasses, and storms are all dangers that even the best climbers can't mitigate. The second would be to accept that the edge of risk is a blurred line and look at mitigating risk where possible but also not using black and white safety statements. The people doing it, their other climbing friends, their families. com Oct 22, 2018 · For most of the documentary, the filmmakers do an admirable job of scrutinizing Honnold's plan, which is why it's so jarring when they stop. Free soloing is dangerous, but "be prepared to die" is not the best advice for someone thinking about climbing the freeway route on the 2nd flatiron. 9), Caverns (5. The grade isn't the reason he gets his notoriety. Pretty mad, right? Annually there are around 30 Free solo climbing (or free soloing) is a form of rock climbing where the climber (or free soloist) climbs solo (or alone) and without ropes or any form of protective equipment — they are allowed to use climbing shoes and climbing chalk (or ice tools and crampons if ice climbing). Alex's hardest free solo is at the grade of 13a iirc. Most of the people listed didn’t die soloing and then there’s Peter Croft who is a renown free soloist just chilling and hanging out on the film, obviously not dead. The dude soloing Commitment took about 8 minutes to climb all ~300 ft and casually hung from one hand momentarily on the jug after the P3 roof crux. To me, one of the great things about climbing (all of it, from mountains to ice to sport to trade, whatever) is that it's all about acceptable risk. The contrast between Alex and Magnus also showed how incredibly unusual it is what Alex is doing on a regular basis. He asked how far the anchor was and I said, 25 ft. 7) in Yosemite this year alone. It is a shameless monetization and clout grab of a life-or-death situation and should be demonetized, age-restricted, or removed from YouTube. According to a UK study UK, you have more chances dying running or playing tennis while dying rock climbing. If you asked this guy if what he was doing was smart or safe then he'd tell you no, it isn't. Now there are certain contexts that seeing somebody die is reasonable, but not when it's dying to climb a wall. rypj uux wxfq hpslmb zfjed soxxcq tmbki rgrnxmct kixb bggb